Reflections & Insights
8 Minute Read
How Do I Trust Myself When I Don’t Know What Comes Next?

Have you ever looked back at a decision you made and wondered how you could have gotten it so wrong? At the time, you thought you were making the best choice. You considered what you knew, weighed your options, and moved forward believing things would work out a certain way. But they didn't. Perhaps the relationship ended, the job wasn't what you hoped, or the change you worked so hard to make brought challenges you never anticipated.
Now you're facing another decision, and something feels different. You hesitate. You question your judgment. You imagine all the ways things could go wrong, and you find yourself asking other people what they think, hoping someone will help you feel certain. You want to move forward, but how do you trust yourself when you don't know what comes next, especially when decisions you've made before haven't turned out the way you expected?
When Past Decisions Make You Question Yourself
It's easy to look back at a decision and judge it by what happened afterward. If things worked out well, you might tell yourself you made the right choice. If they didn't, you might decide you should have known better. You replay conversations, revisit the signs you think you missed, and wonder why you didn't choose differently.
But there's something worth considering. When you made that decision, you didn't know everything you know today. You couldn't see every possibility or predict how other people and circumstances would change. You made a choice from where you were, with the understanding and experiences available to you at that moment.
What if the outcome isn't the only way to understand a decision? What if something not working out as you hoped doesn't automatically mean you were wrong to choose it?
You might recognize that possibility intellectually and still feel afraid to make another choice. Sometimes the hesitation isn't only about what happened last time. It may also be connected to something you've been carrying for much longer.
Where Did the Fear of Getting It Wrong Begin?
Think about what it feels like when you're faced with an important decision. Maybe your mind starts listing everything that could go wrong. You worry about disappointing someone, being criticized, losing something important, or having to explain yourself if things don't work out. Perhaps you keep gathering information because you believe that if you think about it long enough, you'll eventually find the one choice that guarantees a good outcome.
If that sounds familiar, you might become curious about when you first remember feeling that way. Was there a time when making a mistake came with consequences that felt especially difficult? Perhaps someone became angry, withdrew their affection, or made you feel that you should have known better. Or maybe your experiences were entirely different.
Imagine a little girl who learned that making the wrong choice meant disappointing someone she loved. She might have become very good at anticipating what other people wanted, avoiding mistakes, and making decisions that kept everyone happy. Those abilities may have helped her navigate her world. They might even have contributed to some of her greatest accomplishments.
But what happens when that little girl grows into a woman who still feels responsible for getting every decision right?
She may be capable, successful, and trusted by everyone around her, yet struggle to trust herself. The fear of making a mistake can become so familiar that she doesn't notice how much it influences her choices.
Not everyone who struggles with self-trust has a childhood experience like this, and you don't need to uncover one to begin exploring your own decisions. But if an earlier experience comes to mind, it may be worth approaching it with curiosity rather than judgment.
What Might Change If You No Longer Had to Get Every Decision Right?
Imagine for a moment that you could look back at a decision you regret without criticizing yourself for how it turned out. You don't have to pretend the outcome was wonderful or ignore the disappointment you experienced. You simply allow yourself to recognize that you made a choice, life unfolded, and you learned things you couldn't have known beforehand.
If you no longer needed to carry regret about that decision, what might become available to you now?
Perhaps you'd feel free to explore something new. Maybe you'd be willing to take a chance, knowing you could make another choice if things didn't work out. You might discover that you don't need everyone to agree with your decisions or understand why you're making them.
And if you recognize a younger part of yourself that learned to fear mistakes, you might imagine offering her the understanding she needed. What would you want her to know today? How might she feel being acknowledged rather than criticized? What could become possible if she no longer had to protect you from every uncertain outcome?
You don't have to force an answer to any of these questions. Sometimes simply allowing yourself to consider them creates a different experience of the decision in front of you.
Discovering the Gift Within the Tension
Imagine a rope with nervousness about making decisions at one end and excitement about the possibilities at the other. Both are pulling in opposite directions, creating tension and tightening a knot in the middle. Part of you wants to move forward and explore, while another part is afraid of what might happen if you get it wrong.
What if neither part needs to win?
Instead of trying to eliminate the nervousness or convince yourself to be excited, imagine laying the rope down. You might even picture your younger self beside you as you approach the knot together. Rather than pulling it tighter, you begin gently loosening it, curious about what might be held inside.
In my Pattern Weaving work, I often explore the possibility that tension or a repeating pattern may hold a gift we haven't recognized yet. That gift isn't something I can identify for another person. It emerges through their own experience and discovery.
Perhaps the gift you discover is freedom. The freedom to make a choice without knowing exactly how it will turn out. The freedom to change your mind, try again, or choose a different direction. The freedom to listen to yourself even when someone else disagrees.
Or perhaps something entirely different emerges for you.
If you could make decisions knowing you were free to choose again, what would become possible?
What Does Your Inner Knowing Feel Like?
One of the things I've discovered in my own life is that trusting myself feels less like having absolute certainty and more like coming home.
When I connect with my heart and listen to my inner knowing, there's a safe, comfortable feeling. It's familiar, almost as though I'm returning to a place within myself that has always been there. That feeling doesn't necessarily make the fear disappear. I can still feel nervous about what might happen or wonder whether things will work out the way I hope.
But the feeling of coming home is stronger. It's more vibrant than the fear, and when I recognize it, I feel empowered and confident about moving forward.
You may experience inner knowing differently. Perhaps it's a sense of calm, a feeling in your body, a quiet recognition, or simply an awareness that a choice feels aligned with what matters to you. You might not recognize it immediately, especially if you've spent years looking outside yourself for reassurance or approval.
And listening to yourself doesn't mean ignoring practical considerations, advice, or information that could help you make a thoughtful decision. Those things still have value. The difference is that they no longer have to replace your own voice.
You can consider what others think while remaining connected to what feels true for you.
Learning to Trust Yourself Through Small Decisions
If you've spent years questioning your judgment, the idea of trusting your inner knowing with a major life decision might feel overwhelming. You may be considering a career change, a relationship, retirement, or something else that could significantly change your life. It's understandable to want reassurance before taking a step that matters so much.
But you don't have to begin with the biggest decision you're facing.
What if you started with something as simple as deciding what to have for dinner?
Instead of immediately thinking about what everyone else wants, what's easiest, or what you usually make, take a quiet moment and ask your heart what it would enjoy. Perhaps the answer is homemade soup. Before deciding whether that's practical or what you should be eating, notice how the possibility feels within you. Does imagining the warmth and comfort of that soup bring a little joy? Does something about the choice feel inviting?
You might discover a different answer entirely, or you might not notice much at first. That's okay. The point isn't to turn every small decision into an exercise or find a special meaning in everything you choose. It's simply to give yourself opportunities to listen and become familiar with how your own preferences and inner knowing feel.
Over the next few days, you could explore this with other small choices. What would you enjoy doing with a free afternoon? Which route would you like to take on your walk? What sounds appealing when you have a little time just for yourself?
As you become more familiar with listening to yourself in ordinary moments, you may begin feeling more comfortable bringing that same awareness to larger decisions. Not because you've learned to guarantee the right outcome, but because you're strengthening a relationship with yourself that you can return to whenever uncertainty arises.
You Don't Have to Know What Comes Next to Trust Yourself
Perhaps you've been waiting to feel completely certain before making your next decision. You've wanted to know that everything will work out, that no one will be disappointed, and that you won't look back someday wishing you'd chosen differently.
But what if trusting yourself doesn't require any of those guarantees?
What if it means knowing that you can listen to yourself, make a choice, and remain connected to who you are regardless of how things unfold? You can learn from an experience without turning it into evidence that your judgment is flawed. You can recognize fear without allowing it to make every decision for you. And you can consider the expectations of others without letting them determine the direction of your life.
The relationship you're building with yourself doesn't depend on always being right. It grows as you begin recognizing your own inner knowing and giving it a place in the choices you make.
You may not know what comes next. You may still feel nervous. But you can begin discovering what it feels like to trust the person who will be there with you, whatever happens.
Yourself.
A QUESTION TO SIT WITH
The next time you're making a simple decision, take a quiet moment, place a hand over your heart if that feels comfortable, and ask:
“What would I choose if I trusted myself?”
Notice what comes, whether it's a feeling, a thought, or simply silence. You don't need to force an answer. Just begin making room for your own voice.
